Double pulse test using C2M0080120D
Hello,
I'm trying to measure the turn-on and turn-off switching energies (Eon/Eoff) in LTspice using a double-pulse test (DPT) circuit.
However, I'm having trouble getting the expected Eon/Eoff results, and I'm not sure what might be causing the issue.
Based on a previous forum discussion, my understanding is that Eon does not include Coss-related losses, while Eoff includes them.
Is my understanding correct?
If so, is it correct to calculate Eon and Eoff simply by integrating the product of the MOSFET's drain-source voltage (Vds) and drain current (Id) over the switching intervals? Or do I need to consider the Coss-related energy separately?
Also, is there any difference between the LTspice model provided on the manufacturer's website and the actual physical MOSFET, particularly in terms of switching losses?
I would appreciate any clarification or advice.
Thank you!
Comments
-
Thank you for your post, it has been approved and we will respond as soon as possible.
0 -
Hi,
In a hard-switched DPT, we generally think of Coss as charging during turn-off and discharging during turn-on. While not untrue, only looking at the low side device is a simplification of the dynamics, since you also have a high side capacitance. There are papers such as that provide much more detail on this topic.
In a sense though, a fair comparison to datasheet values only requires measuring the energy in simulation in the same manner as it is reported in the datasheet. Please take a look at this document for more details https://assets.wolfspeed.com/uploads/2024/01/Wolfspeed_PRD-03043_Measuring_Switching_and_Conduction…
1.In a double-pulse test (DPT), switching energies are typically extracted by integrating the instantaneous device power, VDS(t) x ID(t), over the turn-on and turn-off intervals; The LTspice model includes the device's nonlinear capacitances (Cgs, Cgd, Cds), then integrating VDS(t) x ID(t) over the switching event should already capture the energy predicted by the model. You don't have to considere the Coss-related energy separately
2. Regarding the difference between the LTspice model and the physical device, the simulation model is intended to represent the electrical behavior of the MOSFET, including switching characteristics and capacitance effects, but it will not perfectly reproduce real-world measurements. Differences can arise from packages and PCB parasitic, Loop inductances, Temperature effects, Gate driver responses, and Device-to-device variations, etc.
As a result, simulated Eon/Eoff values may differ from datasheet values unless the DPT conditions closely match the manufacturer's test setup (bus voltage, load current, gate resistance, gate drive voltage, temperature, and parasitic elements).
If your simulation results differ significantly from the datasheet, I would recommend first verifying that these test conditions match the datasheet characterization conditions before investigating the device model itself.
Hope this helps.
Best,
SudharsanC
0
